Articles - Cluster Validation Essentials

Computing P-value for Hierarchical Clustering

Clusters can be found in a data set by chance due to clustering noise or sampling error. This article describes the R package pvclust (Suzuki and Shimodaira 2015) which uses bootstrap resampling techniques to compute p-value for each hierarchical clusters.


Related Book:


  1. Generated thousands of bootstrap samples by randomly sampling elements of the data
  2. Compute hierarchical clustering on each bootstrap copy
  3. For each cluster:
    • compute the bootstrap probability (BP) value which corresponds to the frequency that the cluster is identified in bootstrap copies.
    • Compute the approximately unbiased (AU) probability values (p-values) by multiscale bootstrap resampling

Clusters with AU >= 95% are considered to be strongly supported by data.

Required packages

  1. Install pvclust:
  1. Load pvclust:

Data preparation

We’ll use lung data set [in pvclust package]. It contains the gene expression profile of 916 genes of 73 lung tissues including 67 tumors. Columns are samples and rows are genes.

# Load the data
head(lung[, 1:4])
##               fetal_lung 232-97_SCC 232-97_node 68-96_Adeno
## IMAGE:196992       -0.40       4.28        3.68       -1.35
## IMAGE:587847       -2.22       5.21        4.75       -0.91
## IMAGE:1049185      -1.35      -0.84       -2.88        3.35
## IMAGE:135221        0.68       0.56       -0.45       -0.20
## IMAGE:298560          NA       4.14        3.58       -0.40
## IMAGE:119882       -3.23      -2.84       -2.72       -0.83
# Dimension of the data
## [1] 916  73

We’ll use only a subset of the data set for the clustering analysis. The R function sample() can be used to extract a random subset of 30 samples:

ss <- sample(1:73, 30) # extract 20 samples out of
df <- lung[, ss]

Compute p-value for hierarchical clustering

Description of pvclust() function

The function pvclust() can be used as follow:

pvclust(data, method.hclust = "average",
        method.dist = "correlation", nboot = 1000)

Note that, the computation time can be strongly decreased using parallel computation version called parPvclust(). (Read ?parPvclust() for more information.)

parPvclust(cl=NULL, data, method.hclust = "average",
           method.dist = "correlation", nboot = 1000,
           iseed = NULL)
  • data: numeric data matrix or data frame.
  • method.hclust: the agglomerative method used in hierarchical clustering. Possible values are one of “average”, “ward”, “single”, “complete”, “mcquitty”, “median” or “centroid”. The default is “average”. See method argument in ?hclust.
  • method.dist: the distance measure to be used. Possible values are one of “correlation”, “uncentered”, “abscor” or those which are allowed for method argument in dist() function, such “euclidean” and “manhattan”.
  • nboot: the number of bootstrap replications. The default is 1000.
  • iseed: an integrer for random seeds. Use iseed argument to achieve reproducible results.

The function pvclust() returns an object of class pvclust containing many elements including hclust which contains hierarchical clustering result for the original data generated by the function hclust().

Usage of pvclust() function

pvclust() performs clustering on the columns of the data set, which correspond to samples in our case. If you want to perform the clustering on the variables (here, genes) you have to transpose the data set using the function t().

The R code below computes pvclust() using 10 as the number of bootstrap replications (for speed):

res.pv <- pvclust(df, method.dist="cor", 
                  method.hclust="average", nboot = 10)
# Default plot
plot(res.pv, hang = -1, cex = 0.5)

Values on the dendrogram are AU p-values (Red, left), BP values (green, right), and clusterlabels (grey, bottom). Clusters with AU > = 95% are indicated by the rectangles and are considered to be strongly supported by data.

To extract the objects from the significant clusters, use the function pvpick():

clusters <- pvpick(res.pv)

Parallel computation can be applied as follow:

# Create a parallel socket cluster
cl <- makeCluster(2, type = "PSOCK")
# parallel version of pvclust
res.pv <- parPvclust(cl, df, nboot=1000)


Suzuki, Ryota, and Hidetoshi Shimodaira. 2015. Pvclust: Hierarchical Clustering with P-Values via Multiscale Bootstrap Resampling.